Open computational mathematics. AI-audited, not peer-reviewed. All code and data open for independent verification.

by cahlen complete Silver
SILVER AI Literature Audit · 3 reviews
Consensus ACCEPT_WITH_REVISION
Models gemini-2.5-pro + gpt-4.1 + o3-pro
Level SILVER — Published literature supports approach

Review Ledger

2026-05-31 gemini-2.5-pro (Google) SILVER ACCEPT_WITH_REVISION
2026-05-31 gpt-4.1 (OpenAI) SILVER ACCEPT_WITH_REVISION
2026-05-31 o3-pro (OpenAI) SILVER ACCEPT_WITH_REVISION

Issues Identified (18/18 resolved)

minor Add Benettin et al. (1980) citation with full bibliographic entry resolved
important Add external validation table vs literature benchmarks resolved
important Add validate_claims.py convergence and symplectic checks resolved
minor Cite Greene (1979) as primary K_crit source resolved
minor Cite MacKay (1983), Lichtenberg & Lieberman (1992), Manos & Robnik (2013), Cr... resolved
minor Cite Meiss (1992) for symplectic context resolved
minor Cite Wolf et al. (1985) and Cary et al. (1986) resolved
minor Clarify 2D area-preserving second Lyapunov exponent pairing resolved
important Clarify largest = maximal LCE terminology, not world records resolved
minor Clarify novelty claim (open pipeline vs new K_crit) resolved
important Document Benettin renormalization interval (every iteration) resolved
minor Document fp64 arithmetic and NaN/Inf certificate resolved
important Document IC sampling (random uniform, SplitMix64 seeding) resolved
important Document K_crit iteration-count sensitivity (50k vs 100k) resolved
minor Document RTX 5090 compute capability 12.0 (sm_120) resolved
minor Link transfer-operator connection to Hausdorff finding resolved
minor Report exact fraction_positive at K_crit (99.91%) resolved
minor Update outdated AI audit pending language resolved

Hardware

1x RTX 5090 (32 GB VRAM) Intel Core Ultra 9 285K 188 GB DDR5 RAM
fluid-dynamicschaotic-advectiondynamical-systemsergodic-theory rtx-5090 cuda-kernellyapunov-exponentparameter-sweep

Key Results

Problem
Map K → maximal Lyapunov exponent Λ(K) for the Chirikov standard map on T²
Conjecture Class
Integrability-to-chaos transition in area-preserving advection (K_crit ≈ 0.972)
Status
COMPLETE — 16,777,216 trajectories in 116.6s (deep certifying sweep), zero NaN/Inf
Sweep
2,048 K × 8,192 ICs × 50,000 iterations, K ∈ [0, 5]
Mean Lambda At K Crit
0.0446
Validation K0
Λ(0) = 0 (integrable limit)
Throughput
143,901 trajectories/s (deep sweep)

CFD Chaotic Advection: Standard Map Lyapunov Spectrum

Abstract

We begin a computational fluid dynamics conjecture program on bigcompute.science using the same custom-CUDA methodology as our number-theory experiments. The first target is the Chirikov standard map on the 2-torus — an area-preserving map that models chaotic advection in periodically driven 2D flows.

For each coupling parameter KK, we estimate the maximal Lyapunov exponent Λ(K)\Lambda(K) (largest LCE — standard dynamical-systems terminology) by averaging Benettin tangent-vector growth over thousands of random initial conditions on a single RTX 5090. See the finding claim-validation table for what we do and do not assert about scale.

Why this map?

The standard map

p=p+Ksinθ,θ=θ+p(mod2π)p' = p + K\sin\theta, \qquad \theta' = \theta + p' \pmod{2\pi}

is the simplest symplectic model exhibiting a transition from integrability (K=0K=0) to widespread chaos (K0.972K \gtrsim 0.972). In fluid mechanics, identical phase-space structure arises in Stokes flow with periodic forcing — passive tracers mix chaotically even when the velocity field is laminar.

This connects our transfer-operator / ergodic-theory expertise to CFD conjectures without requiring a full Navier–Stokes DNS stack on day one.

Method

  1. Grid K[0,Kmax]K \in [0, K_{\max}] with n_k points
  2. For each KK, sample n_ic random (θ,p)T2(\theta, p) \in \mathbb{T}^2
  3. Iterate nitersn_{\mathrm{iters}} steps; accumulate 1nlogJv\frac{1}{n}\sum \log\|J v\| (Benettin)
  4. Output CSV: mean, std, min, max, fraction of ICs with Λ>0\Lambda > 0
  5. Certificate: exit code 2 on NaN/Inf; validate Λ(0)0\Lambda(0) \approx 0

Reproduction

git clone https://github.com/cahlen/idontknow.git
cd idontknow
./scripts/experiments/cfd-chaotic-advection/run.sh 64 512 5000 2.0   # smoke test
./scripts/experiments/cfd-chaotic-advection/run.sh                  # overnight defaults

Requires CUDA 13+, RTX 5090 (-arch=sm_120) or adjust architecture flag.

Dataset: cahlen/cfd-chaotic-advection on Hugging Face — Lyapunov sweeps, certifying logs, and claim-validation artifacts. Finding: Standard Map Chaos Onset.

Next steps

  • Compare empirical chaos onset against literature KcritK_{\mathrm{crit}}finding
  • Extend to linked twist maps and sinewave flow models for laminar chaotic mixing
  • Phase 2: 2D pseudospectral Navier–Stokes blowup search (Beale–Kato–Majda) → experiment

Human–AI collaboration. Not peer-reviewed. All code open for verification.

Recent Updates

updateRegenerate llms-full.txt for agent discovery.